on wanting to disappear

i think one of the hardest things to explain about being suicidal is that everybody wants it to mean something much simpler than it actually means. you want to die. okay. why? because youre miserable. okay. then why didnt you ask for help? because i wanted to disappear. okay. then why did you tell anyone? because maybe some part of me wanted somebody to know. okay. then you must have wanted to live. maybe. or maybe i wanted to die and also wanted somebody to understand that i had existed first. and already the conversation has become annoying. there is a distinction between wanting to die, wanting to stop existing, and wanting whatever is currently happening to stop. these things overlap, obviously, but i dont think theyre interchangeable. i can want to disappear without having any particular interest in the process of dying. i can want somebody to intervene while simultaneously resenting the idea of being prevented from making my own decisions. i can tell somebody how im feeling without necessarily wanting them to do anything about it. and i can understand why none of these distinctions are particularly reassuring to somebody who cares about me. thats part of the problem. i think people have a tendency to interpret expressions of suicidality as though they represent a single, coherent intention. either you want to die or you dont. either youre asking for help or youre not. if you tell somebody, that must mean some part of you wants to be saved. if you conceal it, that must mean youre serious. but these arent mutually exclusive categories. wanting somebody to know what im experiencing doesnt automatically mean i want them to prevent it. wanting to be left alone doesnt mean i want nobody to care about me. sometimes i just want somebody to understand what im saying without immediately turning it into something else. and i recognize how unreasonable that can become. because im effectively asking somebody to acknowledge the possibility of my death without responding to it as though my death is a possibility. wonderful. very workable arrangement. i think a lot about my first attempt, although not necessarily about the attempt itself. what stays with me more consistently is everything that happens around it. the way people behave afterward. the assumptions that become attached to ordinary things. after my first attempt, i oversleep for lunch with my grandfather. everybody panics. they think ive hung myself. im not doing anything particularly unusual. im sleeping. i miss an appointment. something that would ordinarily warrant mild annoyance becomes an indication that i might be dead. my family had learned a new interpretation of silence. and i had taught it to them. and given the available information, i cant even say that their reaction is irrational. thats what bothers me. there is no misunderstanding to correct. no particularly unreasonable assumption to challenge. ive demonstrated that the possibility exists, and now the people around me have to account for it. i had lost the privilege of being unremarkable. another time, im lying awake in bed when my father comes upstairs. i pretend to be asleep. he enters my room, walks over to me, and checks my pulse. i dont move. i dont say anything. i just lie there while my father verifies that im alive. my existence required checking. and i understand why he does it. i know hes afraid. i know he loves me. i know that, from his perspective, the alternative to checking is potentially much worse than making me uncomfortable. but i hate it. i hate that my father feels the need to check whether im alive. i hate that i create a situation where something as ordinary as sleeping becomes a source of concern. and i hate that my reaction to somebody being afraid for me is resentment. because what exactly is he supposed to do differently? ignore the possibility? assume everything is fine? apparently i want him to somehow know that im alive without checking. i want the reassurance to exist without the behavior required to obtain it. and i dont have a particularly convincing argument for why that should be possible. i think this is where my relationship with concern becomes difficult to explain. i dont object to people caring about me. i dont even necessarily object to people being worried about me. i object to the way that concern changes how im allowed to behave. once somebody knows that youve attempted suicide, certain ordinary behaviors acquire additional significance. sleeping too long. not answering your phone. withdrawing from a conversation. having a particularly bad day. saying something dramatic about how much you hate your life. none of these things are inherently remarkable. but now they exist alongside information that changes their interpretation. and i dont know how to undo that. i cant reasonably expect somebody to forget what they know. i cant ask them to treat my history as irrelevant when it clearly isnt. but i also dont want every expression of distress to be evaluated against the worst thing ive ever done. i want to be able to say that i hate my life without having to immediately clarify the extent to which i mean it. which is particularly frustrating because sometimes i do mean it. sometimes i genuinely hate my life. sometimes i wish i could stop being conscious. sometimes i think about everything thats happened and everything that might happen and find the entire arrangement profoundly unappealing. none of that necessarily tells you what im going to do. an expression of distress is not automatically a declaration of intent. but once people know my history, i can feel the conversation changing. the thing im trying to describe stops being the subject. instead, i have to explain what i meant by describing it that way. i can say i wish i could rip a part of my brain out, obviously meaning that i want the experience produced by that part of my brain to stop, not that im proposing amateur neurosurgery. and suddenly the question is whether im safe. i understand why people ask. i understand that sometimes the annoying question is the one that keeps somebody alive. but now im no longer talking about the thing that hurt. im managing the observers reaction to my pain. i have to translate myself into language sufficiently distressed to communicate the severity of the feeling but insufficiently distressed to trigger the protocol. there is a ridiculous rhetorical precision required. once you have crossed certain lines, your metaphors acquire a criminal record. every sentence gets background checked. i want emotional range. i want the right to be dramatic for thirty seconds and then calm down. i want the right to have a terrible day without everybody quietly wondering whether this is The Day. and yet i know that people can be in serious danger without behaving the way anybody expects them to. i know that from experience. i can be miserable and still go to work. i can have an ordinary conversation. i can make jokes. i can play video games, talk about something interesting, or become temporarily absorbed in whatever happens to capture my attention. and none of those things necessarily contradict how im feeling. people seem to expect psychological states to produce relatively consistent behavior. if somebody wants to die, surely they should behave like somebody who wants to die. but what does that even mean? am i supposed to stop finding things funny? stop caring about my responsibilities? stop being interested in anything? i dont suddenly become a different person. im still me. i still have preferences, relationships, interests, obligations. i can care about all of those things while simultaneously questioning whether i want to continue existing. i can also want to continue existing while wishing that i didnt. this is what makes the whole thing so difficult. i want people to understand that expressions of despair dont necessarily predict behavior, but i know that an absence of expressed despair doesnt guarantee safety either. i want them to distinguish between the two, and i cant give them a reliable way to do it. i want to be trusted with my own continued existence. i also know why that trust might be frightening. i think theres something worth examining about my desire to disappear specifically, because it isnt always clear whether i want to stop existing or stop being perceived. those arent the same thing. i spend an enormous amount of time observing myself. evaluating my behavior, my appearance, my decisions, the way other people might interpret me. then, naturally, i monitor the monitoring. i notice an emotion, then i notice myself noticing it, then i wonder whether noticing it changed it. somewhere several layers down, the original experience is still happening. theoretically. and there are moments where i desperately want the entire process to stop. not necessarily because anything particularly terrible is happening in that moment. sometimes im doing something completely ordinary. the problem is that im still present for it. still conscious of myself. still interpreting everything through whatever collection of experiences and assumptions constitutes me. i cant stop being the person experiencing my life. and i cant stop other people from having their own understanding of that person. sometimes i want nobody to look at me. sometimes i want somebody to understand me completely. sometimes those desires occur practically simultaneously. i dont think thats especially mysterious. being understood and being observed arent identical experiences. attention without surveillance. and i think a lot of my resentment comes from situations where i want the former and receive the latter. my father checking my pulse is probably the clearest example. hes responding to something real. hes doing something reasonable. but the interaction doesnt involve me as a person having an experience. it involves my body, and the question of whether or not that body is alive. which is, admittedly, the question hes trying to answer. i dont know what alternative im expecting. maybe i just want the relationship to exist without the history that makes checking necessary. and obviously it cant. there are other things i cant undo, either. losses that cannot be reversed, decisions whose consequences dont politely disappear once i understand them, versions of my life that i will never experience. i think thats part of why discussions about hope irritate me. not because i believe the future is necessarily hopeless, but because i dont think uncertainty justifies optimism any more than it justifies pessimism. uncertainty is not secretly optimism wearing glasses. it is uncertainty. there are things that can improve. there are things that probably wont. there are circumstances that i might eventually experience differently. but some things really are lost. sometimes the counterfactual really would have been better. i can try to build something from what remains without pretending the loss was secretly necessary. and sometimes understanding why something happened doesnt make its consequences any easier to live with. i have a tendency to approach these things intellectually because thats how i approach practically everything. i try to understand what im experiencing. i examine the assumptions underneath it. i look for contradictions, identify the probable causes, construct arguments for and against my own conclusions. and occasionally i arrive at a perfectly reasonable explanation for why im feeling something. wonderful. i still feel it. insight is not anesthesia. i can understand why my father checks my pulse and still hate that he does it. i can recognize that my interpretation of the future is influenced by my current emotional state without suddenly becoming convinced that the future is going to be better. i know that understanding something doesnt necessarily change it. apparently i still expect it to. and i think that expectation creates another problem, because i start treating my inability to reason myself out of suffering as evidence of some additional failure. i know better. i should be able to recognize what im doing. i should be able to stop. but recognizing a psychological process and controlling it are completely different capabilities. i know this. ive explained it to other people. i would never assume that somebody could simply stop experiencing something because they understood where it came from. and then i turn around and expect exactly that from myself. incredible. i think about how certain experiences permanently change what other people know about you. how even if your circumstances change, the knowledge remains. how difficult it is to establish that a particular behavior no longer means what it once might have meant. i want the right to have changed. but i also want to be allowed to remain complicated. i dont want to have to demonstrate perfect psychological stability before somebody believes that im capable of making decisions. i dont want every expression of frustration to become evidence that i shouldnt be trusted with myself. and i dont want to pretend that my history is irrelevant simply because acknowledging it makes me uncomfortable. these are not particularly compatible demands. i know. i think the closest thing i have to a conclusion is that i want people to distinguish between understanding my experience and assuming responsibility for it. i know those things sometimes overlap. i know there are circumstances where somebody reasonably decides that responding is more important than respecting my preferred interpretation of a conversation. but i dont want that to become the default. i want to be able to describe something ugly without being required to immediately make it less ugly. i want to be able to say that sometimes i wish i didnt exist, and have that understood as a statement about how im experiencing my life rather than automatically as a prediction about what im going to do. because sometimes thats all it is. and sometimes it isnt. i dont have a reliable method for reducing that distinction to something another person can determine from a single sentence. which means i also dont have a particularly satisfying solution. i cant make other people forget what happened. i cant guarantee that my behavior will always be interpreted the way i intend. and i cant reasonably expect the people who care about me to treat the possibility of losing me as an abstract philosophical question. i understand all of that. i just wish that understanding it made being on the receiving end any easier. sometimes i think about my father standing beside my bed, checking my pulse while i pretend to be asleep. i dont know whether he remembers that particular night. i do. and i think what bothers me most is that neither of us is doing anything particularly unreasonable. hes afraid that im dead. im afraid of what it means that he has to check. and neither of us says anything. he finds a pulse. he leaves. i stay in bed.