on intelligence
i think i am intelligent.
that sentence feels embarrassing to write, which is probably part of why i need to write it.
there are certain things you are permitted to say about yourself and certain things you are not. you can say that you are hardworking, although ideally someone else should notice first. you can say that you are compassionate, although that one also gets a little suspicious if you say it too loudly. you can say that you are funny because humor is sufficiently unserious that claiming it does not sound like you are placing yourself above anyone. but intelligence is different. saying “i am intelligent” feels almost obscene. it sounds like announcing your own beauty. the socially correct form is to deny it until someone else insists.
so i want to begin there because i do not want this to turn into false modesty. i think i am intelligent. i have enough evidence for that conclusion that pretending otherwise would actually be less honest than saying it. i learn things quickly. i make connections between things that other people sometimes do not make. abstraction comes naturally to me. i can take an idea apart, rotate it, figure out which pieces are structural and which pieces are decoration, and put it back together differently. i am good at noticing contradictions. i am good at constructing models. i am good at finding the hidden premise inside an argument and asking why everyone agreed to it in the first place.
none of this means that i am smart.
that is the distinction i keep coming back to.
“intelligent” and “smart” are usually treated as synonyms, and maybe for most practical purposes they are. i do not really care about defining them correctly. i care about defining them usefully. and for me there is a difference between possessing a certain amount of cognitive machinery and actually knowing how to use it.
intelligence is capacity.
smart is what you do with it. or, maybe more accurately, smart is the ability to convert capacity into outcomes.
and i am not very good at that.
there is something almost humiliating about possessing a tool that you are incapable of using properly. it would almost be easier if i were simply stupid. that sounds cruel, and i do not mean that being less intelligent would make someone less valuable. i mean specifically for me. there would be something comforting about being able to look at the shape of my life and say, well, yes. of course. this is approximately what the machine was capable of producing.
instead i keep having this awful experience of looking at the machine and looking at the output and wondering what the fuck happened in between.
because the output is not nothing. i know that. this is where the argument immediately starts folding back in on itself. i have done things. i have learned things. i have made things. i have passed tests. i have impressed people occasionally. i have managed to construct a life that, from certain angles, probably looks completely ordinary and functional.
but the problem with intelligence is that it gives you the ability to imagine the counterfactual.
not visually, obviously. lucky me. but structurally.
i can see the branching tree.
if this trait had been attached to someone more disciplined.
if it had been attached to someone less afraid.
if it had been attached to someone who started earlier.
if it had been attached to someone whose brain did not spend so much of its processing power watching itself process.
if it had been attached to somebody who could simply decide that something mattered and then consistently behave as though it mattered.
what would they have done with it?
that is the part that hurts.
because i do not think intelligence is particularly rare in the cosmic sense. there are billions of people. there are many people much more intelligent than i am. i am not sitting here imagining myself as some lost einstein whose genius was tragically denied to humanity. that would be ridiculous.
it is actually smaller than that, which makes it worse in a way.
i just think someone else could have done more.
give whatever combination of traits i have to somebody with better executive function, more confidence, a stable sense of identity, less pathological self-observation, whatever. give it to somebody who does not need to interrogate every desire before acting on it. somebody who can want something without immediately opening a tribunal to determine whether the wanting is legitimate.
what would that person have done by now?
that is an unfair question because this hypothetical person does not exist. i have constructed them specifically to possess all of my advantages and none of my disadvantages. of course they outperform me. i have effectively invented a version of myself with cheats enabled and then gotten angry at myself for losing to her.
i know that. simply knowing it does not make the comparison disappear.
that is another difference between intelligence and smartness, maybe. intelligence is very good at demonstrating why your feelings are irrational. smartness would presumably know that this is not the same thing as making them stop.
i can build the prosecution and the defense simultaneously.
the prosecution says: you were given something useful and squandered it.
the defense says: given by whom? squandered relative to what? there was never a designated purpose. a person is not a grant allocation. intelligence is not public infrastructure. you were not issued a brain under the contractual condition that you maximize its economic output.
the prosecution says: cute. look at your life.
the defense says: by which metric?
the prosecution says: exactly.
and around and around it goes.
because i do not even know what “achieved something” means when i say it.
money? i could have made more.
status? i could have pursued more.
academic accomplishment? probably.
some impressive title that makes acquaintances go “wow” when they hear what i do?
a published paper?
a company?
a degree with enough letters after it?
a book?
but then i start pulling on that thread and the whole concept gets strange. there is no neutral unit called achievement. achievement is always achievement of something, and the something has to matter to somebody. usually it matters because we have collectively agreed that it should.
and i am suspicious of collective agreements.
so why does this one have such a grip on me?
why can i recognize that the concept of wasted potential is philosophically incoherent and still feel devastated by it?
potential for what? wasted according to whom?
a seed that never becomes a tree has “wasted potential” only if you assume becoming a tree was an obligation rather than one possible description of what could have happened to it.
but i am not a seed.
i am the thing doing the evaluating.
and unfortunately i know enough to construct standards that i cannot meet.
maybe that is what i mean when i say i am intelligent but not smart.
i can understand systems without understanding how to live inside them.
i can identify the optimal move and still not make it.
i can explain why somebody else is behaving irrationally while watching myself do something equally irrational for reasons that feel completely compelling from inside the machine.
i can notice that i am procrastinating. i can identify the anxiety underneath the procrastination. i can identify the belief underneath the anxiety. i can identify where that belief probably came from. i can explain how avoiding the task reinforces the anxiety by temporarily relieving it.
and then i can continue procrastinating.
amazing. incredible machine. ten out of ten analysis.
zero behavioral changes.
sometimes intelligence feels less like a superpower and more like being given extremely detailed telemetry for a car whose steering wheel has been disconnected.
yes, thank you. i can see that we are heading toward the wall. the dashboard is providing fascinating information about our velocity.
it is difficult not to become contemptuous of yourself under those conditions.
because once you believe you are capable of understanding better, every failure begins to feel less forgivable.
ignorance is an explanation.
confusion is an explanation.
but what explanation is left when you knew?
i knew i should start earlier.
i knew i was avoiding things.
i knew certain problems would become harder if i ignored them.
i knew time was passing.
i knew that “eventually” was not a date.
i knew that understanding why i was stuck was not the same thing as becoming unstuck.
and somehow i think the fact that i knew all of this should have saved me.
it did not.
so knowledge starts feeling almost incriminating.
you knew better.
that sentence has probably done more psychological damage than most insults ever could.
you knew better.
yes. i did.
what now?
there is another assumption hiding in all of this, though, and i think it is probably the ugliest one.
when i say that intelligence was wasted on me, i am treating intelligence as though it belongs to the world before it belongs to the person who has it.
like it is a resource that should have been allocated efficiently.
like somewhere there was a limited supply of intelligence and some bureaucratic error put too much of it in my skull when it could have been distributed to somebody more productive.
somebody would have made better use of this.
somebody else deserved it more.
deserved.
there it is.
because beneath “wasted” is always a moral judgment.
if you waste food, somebody hungry could have eaten it.
if you waste money, it could have been spent on something worthwhile.
if you waste time, you could have been doing something productive.
waste means that a resource had a better use.
and if i was a waste of intelligence, then the implicit conclusion is that there was a better use for me.
or, more precisely, for the useful components of me.
take this part out. put it somewhere else. maybe then something worthwhile happens.
which is such a grotesquely economic way to understand a person that i would immediately reject it if somebody applied it to anyone else.
i would never look at a brilliant person who struggled with addiction, or mental illness, or poverty, or trauma, or disability, or simple indecision, and think, wow, what an inefficient allocation of cognitive resources.
i would understand immediately that the intelligence and the struggle belong to the same person.
there is no clean procedure where we extract the desirable trait and transplant it into somebody who will generate a higher return.
the person is the configuration.
and yet when the person is me, suddenly i become an underperforming asset.
funny how that works.
i think part of it is that intelligence became one of the few things about myself that i could reliably believe was good.
not morally good. just useful.
measurable, sometimes.
something that could justify me.
and once a trait becomes part of your justification for existing, it acquires obligations.
if being intelligent is one of the reasons i am worthwhile, then i had better produce something worthy of that intelligence.
otherwise what was the point?
it makes intelligence simultaneously the thing i am proudest of and the thing i can most effectively use to hurt myself.
because every accomplishment becomes the minimum expected return.
of course you did well. you are intelligent.
how can i feel proud of something i did not work for? for something that i did not earn?
and every failure becomes evidence of some deeper defect.
how did you fuck this up? you are intelligent.
there is no winning condition.
success proves nothing.
failure proves everything.
i would never accept evidence under those conditions in any other context.
but again: analysis is not liberation.
sometimes it just means the prison has excellent documentation.
and maybe the deepest frustration is that i can feel there is something in me that wants to be used.
not in the capitalist productivity sense. not necessarily in the “work eighty hours and build an empire” sense.
i mean there is this restless thing in me that wants to understand, construct, articulate, discover, connect. i genuinely enjoy thinking. i enjoy the feeling of an idea clicking into place. i enjoy taking something vague and finding language precise enough to hold it. i enjoy the moment when two things that seemed unrelated suddenly reveal themselves as the same shape.
that part does not feel fake.
and so when my life feels small, i do not merely feel unsuccessful.
i feel underexpressed.
that might be the word.
not wasted, but underexpressed.
there is more internal complexity than external evidence of it.
and i think i have been translating that mismatch into self condemnation because condemnation gives it a cleaner explanation.
why has so little come out?
because you are lazy.
because you are defective.
because you squandered it.
because somebody else would have done better.
those explanations hurt, but they have the virtue of being simple.
the alternative is that people are complicated systems and output is nonlinear and intelligence is only one variable among hundreds and human beings are not optimization problems.
boring.
deeply unsatisfying.
where is the villain?
i would like the villain to be me because at least then the story has one.
then there is something to blame.
there is something almost reassuring about saying “i wasted it.” it implies control. it implies that all of this happened because i made the wrong choices, which means there was a coherent alternate path where i made the right ones.
but lives are not usually that legible.
there were choices, yes.
there were also circumstances.
there were traits, fears, things i didnt understand. things i did but couldnt act on.
there were years where simply being myself was complicated enough that demanding impressive external achievement on top of it might have been asking for an impossible degree of coordination from a person who was still trying to figure out what the fuck the person even was.
and i hate writing that because it sounds like making excuses.
i have a complicated relationship with excuses.
i think anything that explains me starts feeling suspiciously like an attempt to acquit me.
apparently i am very invested in securing a conviction.
but explanation is not acquittal and context is not innocence.
i can acknowledge that i made mistakes without turning those mistakes into proof that the entire allocation was erroneous.
i can regret lost time without constructing a hypothetical more deserving recipient for my own brain.
and maybe most importantly, i have to recognize that the argument is not over.
that sounds dangerously optimistic, so naturally i want to qualify it immediately.
i am not saying “actually none of the time was wasted! everything happens for a reason! your journey made you who you are!!!”
some time probably was wasted.
some opportunities probably were lost.
there are things i could have done that i did not do.
there are versions of my life that i would prefer to the one i have lived.
i am allowed to grieve that without pretending every detour was secretly necessary.
but “i wasted time” is a very different sentence from “intelligence was wasted on me.”
one describes events.
the other describes a person.
and maybe that is where i keep getting caught. i take regrets about what i did and convert them into judgments about what i am.
i did not use this well enough, therefore i was the wrong person to receive it.
but receive it from where?
again, the allocation office does not exist.
this intelligence is not sitting inside me as a foreign object whose rightful owner is somewhere out there curing cancer and composing symphonies while wondering why she feels vaguely underclocked.
it is me.
including the stupid parts. maybe especially the stupid parts.
the contradictions are not defects in the transfer.
i am the particular machine that exists.
and maybe the real challenge is deciding what to do with the machine now rather than conducting an endless postmortem on why it was not a different machine earlier.
which sounds incredibly obvious when written down.
i hate when the obvious thing survives analysis.
but there is still something important in the original distinction.
i do want to become smarter.
not more intelligent. i do not know that i can meaningfully control that, and i am not convinced i need to.
smarter.
better at translating understanding into behavior.
better at letting a decision remain decided.
better at tolerating imperfect action.
better at recognizing that insight which produces no change is sometimes just elaborate spectatorship.
better at noticing when analysis has stopped being inquiry and become avoidance wearing glasses.
better at saying: yes, there are seventeen additional implications here. no, we do not have to resolve all of them before sending the email.
maybe that is the actual use for whatever intelligence i have.
using it to figure out how to live with myself instead of perpetually auditing myself.
i still feel the waste.
i suspect i will continue to.
i can picture conceptually, god forbid, a version of me who started everything ten years earlier and did everything correctly and emerged at twenty-seven with a magnificent pile of accomplishments, fully formed and completely certain of herself.
i know she is fictional.
i am still very much so jealous of her.
but i am starting to wonder whether the cruelty of that comparison has less to do with believing she would have achieved more and more to do with believing achievement would have made her easier to love.
that is the bargain underneath all of it, isn't it?
if i had done enough, then perhaps i would finally feel that the intelligence had landed in the correct person.
if i had produced enough evidence, or accumulated enough accomplishments.
if i became undeniable, then maybe i could stop feeling like a clerical error.
and there is no amount of achievement that can actually answer that question because the question is malformed.
achievement can tell me what i have achieved.
it cannot tell me whether i was the correct person to be.
there is no correct person to be.
there is only this horribly specific one. me.
stupid with genuinely impressive consistency.
capable of understanding myself with extraordinary precision right up until the exact moment that understanding would need to become action.
someone who has spent an absurd amount of time thinking about whether she has spent too much time thinking.
someone who has absolutely wasted some opportunities.
someone who has also, despite my best efforts to phrase myself as a finished tragedy, not actually reached the end of the dataset.
and i think that last part matters.
because “wasted potential” is something you can only calculate after deciding that the period of possible use is over.
otherwise what you are describing is not waste.
it is capacity, and capacity can still be used.
and maybe somebody else would have used it better.
probably.
there are eight billion people. statistically, i am comfortable conceding that somewhere on earth exists a person who could outperform me at being me.
how wonderful for her.
she does not get to. i do.
that is not a statement of self love. i am not trying to force this into something inspirational. there is no swelling music here. i am not suddenly grateful for every mistake or convinced that i am secretly destined for greatness.
i just think there is something intellectually dishonest about treating the hypothetical maximum value of a life as though it were the minimum acceptable one.
and i have been doing that to myself for a very long time.
but the intelligence was not wasted on me.
there was nowhere else for it to go.